This paper proposes an interesting reading grid for how Open Integrity positions itself in terms of a participative effort.
In the question of "who?" the paper proposes Hierarchy and Crowd as possible "Genes". In that sense Open Integrity is both an expertise led effort - where community of practices are an organising principle - and a Crowd-led or open participation project in the sense that it doesn't enforce any control on who can participate and allows anonymous participation.
As a consequence there should be clear rules of engagement (including a meritocratic assignment of moderation roles) and an enforced code of conduct.
The question of incentives is one that we've been thinking about a lot. The question is posed for each of the potential participants in the OII effort which are:
In addition more broadly, in the Open Integrity Ecosystem we engage with the following stakeholders in interactions that also have participative and collective intelligence aspects:
We'll develop our thoughts progressively on incentives on this platform, and use the paper's "Genes" - Money, Love, Glory - as a grid to exercise our thinking.
Again different part of Open Integrity have different approaches with regards to what the collective effort aims for. Broadly speaking:
|Framework - Impact||users/responders||mission||create - Report||collection|
|Framework - Impact||users/responders||mission||decide - Verify||consensus|
|Framework - Impact||users/responders||mission||decide - Analyse||consensus|
|Framework - Practices||experts||love/glory?||create - Practices||collection|
|Framework - Practices||experts||love/glory?||decide - Best||consensus|
|Framework - Metrics||"measurers"||love/glory?||create - Sources||individual|
|Framework - Metrics||"measurers"||love/glory?||create - Agents||individual|
|Framework - Metrics||iilab / advisors||mission||decide - Taxonomy||consensus|
|Data||developers||glory/money||create/update - Entries||individual|
|Data||reviewers||love/glory?||create/update - Entries||individual|
|Data||job seekers||money||create/update - Entries||individual|
|Data||reviewers||love/glory?||create - Claims||individual|
|Data||moderators||love/glory?||decide - Dispute||consensus|